Scottsdale ruling on public drunkenness draws fire

Posted by Craig Penrod | Sep 09, 2013 | 0 Comments

Scottsdale Judge says state law prohibits arrests

by Beth Duckett- Feb.  6,  2012 09:22 PM The Republic |

A recent court ruling barring Scottsdale police from arresting rowdy drunk  people in public has drawn a spotlight on a decades-old Arizona law that says  cities and towns cannot enforce their own drunken-behavior laws.

The Dec. 20 ruling from Scottsdale City Judge James Blake has prompted  residents, police officials and lawmakers to explore ways to counteract the  ruling, which could open the door for local governments to adopt and enforce  their own laws on public drunkenness.

Blake ruled that Scottsdale's code governing drunkenness is in violation of a  state law that took effect in 1974, barring counties and municipalities from  adopting or enforcing local laws related to intoxication.

Scottsdale is appealing the ruling.  For now, police officers can no longer arrest or cite people heavily under the influence of alcohol in public whenthey pose a danger to themselves or others.

Municipal concerns

Ken Strobeck, executive director of the League of Arizona Cities and Towns,  said local enforcement of drunkenness has been on the radar of several Arizona  communities, particularly Winslow, Holbrook and Page, which are concerned about  inebriated people on their streets.

Sen. Sylvia Allen, R-Snowflake, sponsored a bill this session that would have  addressed some of the concerns.

Allen decided to hold off on a Senate committee vote on the bill after  opponents brought up concerns.

Senate Bill 1082 proposes to, among other things, allow cities and counties  to regulate drive-through liquor sales and the sales of beer in containers that  are 40 ounces or larger.

“I'm still working on the bill — it isn't dead,” said Allen, who called it  “wrong” not to allow communities to “solve particular local problems.”

In 2011, Allen sponsored Senate Bill 1177 that would have allowed  municipalities to adopt and enforce their own intoxication laws. Senate  leadership never scheduled it for a vote of the full Senate.

According to the Scottsdale city attorney, the ruling does not reverse prior  convictions for public intoxication.

In a city known for its booming nightlife, neighbors and business owners are  concerned that the ruling makes it harder for law enforcement to crack down on  overly drunk revelers in the city's downtown-entertainment district.

The district, east of Scottsdale Road and south of Camelback Road, is heavily  populated with nightclubs and bars, drawing revelers from across the Valley and  from out of town.

“It would be a giant step backwards for our public-safety programs,” said  Bill Crawford, a downtown resident and business owner who is president of the  Association to Preserve Downtown Scottsdale's Quality of Life.

Phoenix's outlook

Phoenix spokeswoman Toni Maccarone said the city has a drunk-and-disorderly  ordinance, which makes it a misdemeanor to be in a public place, street, alley  or sidewalk in a drunk or disorderly condition.

City officials were not immediately available to comment on the state law's  effects on Phoenix's ordinance.

Scottsdale's code on public drunkenness has been a “huge tool, especially in  the downtown area,” said Jim Hill, president of the Police Officers of  Scottsdale Association.

Sgt. Mark Clark, a Scottsdale police spokesman, said officers will not ignore  people who are inebriated and pose a danger to themselves or others. Because  disorderly-conduct and other laws still apply, officers can cite and arrest  drunks if they are a nuisance, he noted.

“We're still concerned about the intoxicated people in the neighborhood,”  Clark said. “We'll still respond.”

Republic reporter Ofelia Madrid contributed to this  article.

About the Author

Craig Penrod

Craig W. Penrod was born and raised in Arizona and has practiced criminal defense for over 30 years. Mr. Penrod is a member of the State Bar of Arizona, Maricopa County Bar Association, State of Nevada Bar Association, American Bar Association, American Trial Lawyers Association, Arizona Trial Lawyers Association, Nevada Trial Lawyers Association, Arizona Attorneys for Criminal Justice and the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers.


There are no comments for this post. Be the first and Add your Comment below.

Leave a Comment

Law Offices of Craig W. Penrod

Penrod footer logo 2

You can depend on our Arizona DUI attorneys and Arizona criminal lawyers if you’ve been charged with driving while intoxicated and/or need a criminal defense. DWI attorneys offer essential legal representation and protect your rights. Make sure you have an Arizona DUI lawyer or Arizona criminal attorney protecting your interests.

Contact Us Today!

Contact our Arizona DUI attorneys and Arizona criminal lawyers for your defense. Our Arizona DUI lawyers and Arizona criminal attorneys are here to protect your rights. Our Phoenix criminal attorneys and Phoenix DUI lawyers will work with you to present the best possible defense.